Detection and optimization of content in the payloads of API messages

ABSTRACT

A server in a content delivery network (CDN) can examine API traffic and extract therefrom content that can be optimized before it is served to a client. The server can apply content location instructions to a given API message to find such content therein. Upon finding an instance of such content, the server can verify the identity of the content by applying a set of content verification instructions. If verification succeeds, the server can retrieve an optimized version of the identified content and swap it into the API message for the original version. If an optimized version is not available, the server can initiate an optimization process so that next time the optimized version will be available. In some embodiments, an analysis service can assist by observing traffic from an API endpoint over time, detecting the format of API messages and producing the content location and verification instructions.

BACKGROUND Technical Field

This patent document generally relates to the optimization of contentthat is embedded in API messages.

Brief Description of the Related Art

Hypertext markup language (HTML) is a well-documented standard thatprovides specific mechanics for inlining and referencing certain kindsof content in the HTML, such as images, JavaScript (JS), Cascading StyleSheets (CSS), URLs, and otherwise. Using these mechanics, CDNs and otherintermediaries have built services to optimize HTML messages along withthe content that is inlined/referenced within. For example, U.S. Pat.No. 8,788,577, owned by the assignee hereof, describes methods andsystems for automated analysis and transformation of web pages; see alsoU.S. Pat. No. 9,785,621, the contents of both of which are herebyincorporated by reference.

An increasing share of traffic on the Internet is related to applicationprogramming interfaces (APIs), as shown by Vargas et al.,“Characterizing JSON Traffic Patterns on a CDN” IMC '19, Oct. 21-23,2019, Amsterdam, Netherlands, pp. 195-201. APIs offer a wide range ofservices to end-users and devices. On the Internet, APIs are reachablevia an API endpoint, which is typically in the form of a URL, such asapi.example.com/endpoint123/. A client device, whether operated by ahuman or running automated routines, can send requests for service tothe API endpoint. Such requests often include a set of input parameters.The API typically responds with a message having a payload that inlinesor references certain content. However, unlike HTML, APIs do not havestandards in place to recommend how API messages should be developed,what kinds of content they can inline/reference, what criteria must besatisfied before content is inlined/referenced, and how that contentshould be accessed by client applications. The lack of such standardshas allowed API developers to be independent and flexible in how theybuild and structure API messages and the associated payloads. Forexample, two API payloads may inline or reference exactly the sameinformation but may be structured differently. Similarly, the same APIpayload can be structured in many different ways.

APIs typically (but without limitation) use an HTTP messaging format. AnAPI message over HTTP/1.x can have a start-line, one or more headers andcan have a payload (the term “payload” is sometimes referred to as a“body”; the terms are equivalent and have no difference in meaning forpurposes hereof). Similarly, HTTP/2 and later versions can have one ormore headers (some of the headers containing information previouslyprovided in the start-line) and a payload. APIs often convey the messagepayload using data-interchange formats, such as JSON, CSV, or XML. Whilesuch data-interchange formats may define some aspects of a payload, anAPI may inline many different types of content, in a variety of ways.For example, while JSON is structured as key-value, there is no standardon the number or naming of key-value pairs, where in the payload theycan be placed, or how many there can be. As mentioned above, the clientis assumed to know how to extract the content. Generalizing, unlike theHTML specification, API messages use arbitrary formats to inline orreference content, in that there is no standard on how or where to put aparticular instance of content into the message. There are numerous waysto do so.

APIs fill payloads with not only plain-text strings, numbers, andbooleans into API messages, but also JSON, XML, comma separated values(CSV), tab separated values (TSV), images, JavaScript, CSS, HTML, andother types of content in arbitrary places. This makes it difficult forCDNs and other intermediaries to optimize the API messages. For example,it is known in the art for an image optimization service offered by aCDN to optimize an HTML document that contains image bytes in itsentirety (i.e., an inlined image). However, the same service cannotoptimize image bytes that are inlined in the payload of an API messagebecause both the existence and specific location of the image bytes inthe payload are unknown to the CDN software, being typically proprietaryto the API solution. Generalizing, a CDN cannot apply known optimizationtechniques to a wide range of content types in API messages because itcannot locate or verify instances of such content.

While a CDN could be manually configured with knowledge of the messageformat used by each API being handled on the CDN, such an approach wouldrequire immense resources and soon be out of date, as APIs arecontinually being changed and new APIs are being deployed.

This patent document addresses the technical challenges inherent inoptimizing and serving content embedded in API traffic on the Internet.This patent document discloses novel ways for a CDN to detect andoptimize arbitrarily inlined/referenced content in API payloads,including but not limited to, images, HTML, JS, CSS, URLs. In this way,the teachings herein increase the efficiency and utility of networkcommunications and Internet content delivery systems.

More information about CDN technologies, including examples of requestrouting mechanisms using DNS and otherwise, as well as proxy servertechnologies, can be found in the following documents, the teachings ofwhich are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety: U.S. Pat.Nos. 6,108,703; 7,293,093; 7,096,263; 7,096,266; 7,484,002; 7,523,181;7,574,499; 7,240,100; 7,603,439; 7,725,602; 7,716,367; 7,996,531;7,925,713; 7,058,706; 7,251,688; 7,274,658; 7,912,978; 8,195,831.

The teachings presented herein improve the functioning of a computersystem itself, improving the caching function in an individual server aswell as that of a larger distributed system comprised of many suchservers. Those skilled in the art will understand these and otherimprovements from the teachings hereof.

BRIEF SUMMARY

This section describes some pertinent aspects of this invention. Theyare illustrative, not exhaustive, and they are not a definition of theinvention. The claims of any issued patent define the scope ofprotection.

A server in a content delivery network (CDN) can be configured toexamine API traffic and extract therefrom content of interest, e.g.,content that can be optimized in some way before being delivered to aclient. Given an API message received from a particular API, a CDNserver can use content location instructions for that API to find one ormore instances of inlined content in the API message that can beoptimized. Typically, but without limitation, such instances of inlinedcontent are found in the payload of the API message. The contentlocation instructions specify how to find the content given thearbitrary format of the API message.

Upon locating what appears to be an instance of inlined content that canbe optimized, the CDN server can verify the identity of the content byapplying a set of content verification instructions associated with theAPI. If the identity of the content can be verified (e.g., the contentrepresents image ‘xyz’) the CDN server can retrieve an optimized versionof the identified content and swap that version into the API message,removing the original content. If an optimized version is not available,the CDN server can initiate a content optimization process. Typicallysuch a process is performed out of band, so that next time the optimizedversion will be available in cache or other repository. However, theoptimization process could be done on the fly if doing so did notunacceptably delay the delivery of the API message to the client.

In some embodiments, an analysis service can assist the CDN server byobserving traffic from an API over time and detecting the format of APImessages emitted therefrom, including the location of inlined contenttherein that could benefit from optimization. From this intelligence,the aforementioned content location and content verificationinstructions can be generated for the CDN server. These instructions canbe prepared in advance, and they can be relatively streamlined, so thatthe CDN server can apply them quickly. Moreover, the analysis servicecan develop a confidence score indicating the confidence that a givenAPI message from the API's endpoint truly will conform to the predictedformat and contain the inlined content of interest at the designatedlocation. Using this confidence score, the server can decide in realtime whether to incur the computing cost (e.g., latency, processingload) needed to attempt to locate and verify the inlined content in theAPI message, as compared to the benefit that an optimized version ofcontent would provide.

The claims are incorporated by reference into this section, in theirentirety.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The invention will be more fully understood from the following detaileddescription taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, inwhich:

FIG. 1A is a diagram showing how a CDN server can optimize content inAPI response messages, in accordance with one embodiment of theinvention;

FIG. 1B is a diagram showing how a CDN server can optimize content inAPI response messages, in conjunction with an Offline Analysis Service(OAS), in accordance with one embodiment of the invention; and,

FIG. 2 is a block diagram illustrating hardware in a computer systemthat may be used to implement the teachings hereof.

Numerical labels are provided in some FIGURES solely to assist inidentifying elements being described in the text; no significance shouldbe attributed to the numbering unless explicitly stated otherwise.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

The following description sets forth embodiments of the invention toprovide an overall understanding of the principles of the structure,function, manufacture, and use of the methods and apparatus disclosedherein. The systems, methods and apparatus described in this patentdocument and illustrated in the accompanying drawings are non-limitingexamples; the claims alone define the scope of protection that issought. The features described or illustrated in connection with oneexemplary embodiment may be combined with the features of otherembodiments. Such modifications and variations are intended to beincluded within the scope of the present invention. All patents, patentapplication publications, other publications, and references citedanywhere in this document are expressly incorporated herein by referencein their entirety, and for all purposes. The term “e.g.” used throughoutis used as an abbreviation for the non-limiting phrase “for example.”

The teachings hereof may be realized in a variety of systems, methods,apparatus, and non-transitory computer-readable media. It should also benoted that the allocation of functions to particular machines is notlimiting, as the functions recited herein may be combined or splitamongst different hosts in a variety of ways.

Any reference to advantages or benefits refer to potential advantagesand benefits that may be obtained through practice of the teachingshereof. It is not necessary to obtain such advantages and benefits inorder to practice the teachings hereof.

Basic familiarity with well-known web page, streaming, and networkingtechnologies and terms, such as HTML, URL, XML, AJAX, CSS, JS, HTTPversions 1.1 and 2, HTTP over QUIC, MQTT, TCP/IP, and UDP, is assumed.Likewise, basic familiarity with well-known data-interchange formats,such as JSON, CSV, XML, is assumed.

All references to HTTP should be interpreted to include an embodimentusing encryption (HTTP/S), such as when TLS secured connections areestablished. The terms “client” and “client device” are used herein torefer to hardware in combination with software (e.g., a browser orplayer application). While context may indicate the hardware or thesoftware exclusively, should such distinction be appropriate, theteachings hereof can be implemented in any combination of hardware andsoftware. Hardware may be actual or virtualized.

The term “optimize”, as in optimizing content, does not necessarily meanreducing the size of an instance of content to the smallest possiblesize, or creating the absolute maximally efficient or effective versionof content. Optimization refers to changing content to improve orenhance a relevant aspect of its delivery, display, and/or use. It mayinclude producing a version of content adapted to thecapabilities/attributes of a given end-user client device that requestedit, network quality between the client and a CDN server, or anattribute/preference of the end-user. It may include compressing content(not limited to GZip or Brotli, but including new compression formatssuch as Concise Binary Object Representation (CBOR)), minifying content,or removing unnecessary data from content. The choice of a givencompression level in certain algorithms may be made to compress at thehighest level; or lower than the highest possible level in order tomanage system resources or to expedite completion time. It may includerearranging or otherwise modifying data in content so that it can beprocessed by a client application in a more efficient way or presentedto a user more effectively. It may include hinting for download orpushing the client device of possible resources that the client may needin the near future. Hence a wide range of modifications that improve orenhance content to some degree can be considered optimizations. Thedegree of improvement or enhancement may vary widely. Sometimes, only asmall degree of improvement is achievable given other systemconstraints, design goals; in other situations, a considerableperformance improvement might be gained. Occasionally, the optimizationsystem may experience an instance where optimization “fails” in thesense that, e.g., the resultant file size was expected to be smaller butis larger due to the natural operation of the algorithm applied; in someembodiments this may be detected and the optimization withdrawn.

As noted in the Background, an API message may be formatted as an HTTPmessage with a start-line, header(s) and payload (body), but this is notnecessary. A variety of formats can be used for application layermessaging. And an API message may be considered a payload or bodywithout necessarily being HTTP.

The following description talks about instances of inlined or referencedcontent in the payloads of API messages. Here is a non-limiting exampleof a payload of an API message that is formatted using JSON:

{  ″productName″: ″Marker Pens″,  ″productSKU″: 123456,  ″imageUrl″:″https://examplecustomer.com/products/123456″,  ″imageData″:″(JD0ou3kmi393d8mijdkm3j3oihdkid9ki3dki3dkiDkieki3....″,  ″imageClick″:″app://<openInstalledApp>″,  ″widget″: {   ″header″: ″Email RegistrationError″,   ″stylesheet″: ″https://examplecustomer.com/css/file1.css″,  ″customStyle″: ″#header { background: #f0f007; blue; }″,  ″JSSnippet″: ″var userProfile=getUUID( );function loadErrorMessage(){if(errorCode==1) {displayAlternative( )} else {exitPage(1);} }″,  ″structure″: ″<div><span>Please check your emailaddress</span><br/><span>Click <a href=′somelink′>here</a> to recoverpassword</span></div>″  },  ″userActionJS″: ″deleterenewProfile.user;var initSession=document.location;″ }

The above JSON-formatted payload has several instances of inlinedcontent: a PNG image referred to as “imageData”, a script named“JSSnippet” and another script named “userActionJS”, HTML, named“structure”, CSS named “customStyle”, and multiple URLs (such as“ImageURL”, “stylesheet”). Each of the multiple URLs may point toadditional content, and that linked content can be considered to be‘referenced’ in the payload of this API message.

Each of the aforementioned instances of inlined or referenced content isof a type that can be optimized by CDN servers. How to do so will bedescribed below. It is noted that the term “inlined” content issometimes referred to as “embedded” content; the terms are equivalentand have no difference in meaning for purposes hereof.

1.0 Overview

The embodiments described in the following sections assume an API thatprovides a service and is reachable at an associated API endpoint (e.g.,a URL with hostname and path). FIG. 1 illustrates a basic arrangement,in which a client 100 issues a request to the API running on the originserver 103. The request is received by the CDN server 101 and proxiedforward to the API endpoint 102 hosted on the API's origin server 103.The API endpoint 102 responds with an API message (“API response”) fordelivery to a client 100.

The example of FIG. 1A shows how an API message may be a response to aprevious request made by the client to the API. It should be noted that,in alternative embodiments, the API origin server 103 may send an APImessage without the triggering client request shown in FIG. 1A. In otherwords, the API message emitted by the API may be initiated by an out ofband process or due to some predetermined schedule or conditions.

Upon the CDN server 101 receiving the downstream API response message,the CDN server 101 can attempt to optimize content in the payload. Ingeneral this process can involve locating any instances of inlined orreferenced content in the API payload that can be optimized, verifyingthe identity of such content, and swapping optimized versions of thecontent for the original versions thereof. The computing work needed forthe CDN server to know how to locate and verify and otherwise optimizeinstances of inlined or referenced content can be performed on-the-flyat the time of receiving and scanning the response. Alternatively, suchwork can be done in advance by another service, or a combination of thetwo, so that such content location and/or verification instructions canbe developed and available in advance.

For convenience of description, the following sections focus on theoptimization of instances of inlined content. The optimization ofinstances of referenced content is addressed afterwards.

2.0 on the Fly Detection and Optimization

On-the-fly detection and optimization refers to a CDN server performingthe detection and optimization of content inlined in an API message asit is received from the API for delivery to a client, without previouslydeveloped knowledge or instructions for messages from that API. Thismeans that the API message can be optimized even if it is the first timethat such a message has been encountered.

On-the-fly detection and optimization at a CDN server can be problematicbecause it slows the response time to the client. Nevertheless, incertain cases, such as where an API payload is smaller than specifiedsize (e.g., a configured number of bytes), where the API payload is notcacheable on the CDN, or its structure changes frequently, on-the-flyoptimization may be worthwhile. A configuration installed on theimplementing CDN can evaluate such factors and determine whether anon-the-fly approach should be taken.

The process for on-the-fly optimization can proceed as follows.

2.1 Detect Format

First, the CDN server would detect the format of the API messagepayload. For example, whether a payload is structured as a JSON object,as an XML object, a delimiter-separated-value format (e.g.,comma-separated, CSV, or tab-separated-values, TSV), or some otherdata-interchange format. To detect the format of the payload, theimplementing CDN could check for the presence of the content-typeresponse header from the origin. Alternatively, the entire or parts ofthe payload could be checked for syntactical validations for (withoutlimitation) a JSON object, followed by a check for an XML object,followed by a check for a valid CSV, and so on.

2.2 Detect Inlined Content that can be Optimized

Once the format of the payload is detected, next the CDN server canparse the structure and iterate over all fields in that format to checkfor the presence of a mime-type of interest. For example, if a payloadis structured as a JSON object, the server can iterate over allkey-value pairs, including array elements, nested objects, and arrays orobjects quoted as strings. If the payload is structured as XML, iterateover all child tags. If the payload is a CSV, iterate over alldelimiter-separated fields.

While iterating over the payload, the CDN server may scan for instancesof inlined content pertaining to one or more of the followingmime-types: base64 encoded image bytes, JavaScript, HTML, CSS, URLs,etc. For each of the scanned bytes, the CDN server can perform a seriesof operations to check whether the scanned bytes contain one of thesemime-types of interest. Below are a few example ways on how content canbe classified into different mime-types:

-   -   Base64 encoded images start with data:image/<format>; base64 The        presence of this string at the start can be used to detect the        presence of inlined images.    -   HTML detection can be performed by first making sure that the        payload has a valid HTML syntax, followed by checking for the        presence of valid HTML tags. For example, <xyz></xyz> is        syntactically correct but is not valid HTML. A W3C HTML        validator could be utilized for the most accurate validation.    -   CSS could be detected by first checking for syntactical errors,        followed by checking for allowed CSS rules. For example, a        {color:hello;} is a syntactically correct CSS but hello is not a        valid CSS color. For the most accurate validation, a CSS        validator service/tool such as that offered by the W3C (which is        currently named Jigsaw) can be used.    -   For detecting JS, the payload could be passed through a JS        parser, such as esprima, to check for valid JS code. Since a JS        parser would treat strings and numerals as valid JS bodies, the        payload should be passed through a second check to detect the        presence of popular JS keywords, such as var, let, const,        function, module.exports, console.    -   For detecting URLs in the payload, a regex could be developed to        detect HTTP, HTTPS, APP, WEBPACK, and other URLs.

For payloads that don't directly match one of the above mime-types, itis possible that the payload is base64 encoded. To check if that is thecase, the payload can be base64 decoded and then re-encoded as base64and the final output is compared with the original payload. If the twomatch, then the payload is base64 encoded and should be decoded andchecked for the presence of the valid image, CSS, HTML, or JS bytes(using the processes already mentioned above).

When the CDN server needs to iterate over a payload, it may keep a bytecount of each of the various mime-types that are inlined in the payload(e.g., plain-text strings, boolean, and numbers). Doing so enables newkinds of optimizations, such as compressing with algorithms that aresuited to the content type in the payload (discussed further below inadditional use cases section).

2.3 Extract Inlined Content

If an instance of inlined content is detected, the implementing CDN canextract the corresponding bytes for further processing if theconfiguration allows. For example, certain types of content in the APIpayload may be disallowed for further processing or only a limitednumber of instances of inlined content may be allowed for processing ata time.

2.4 Verify Identity of Inlined Content and Check Cache for PreviouslyGenerated Optimized Version Thereof

The goal of content verification is to ensure with a high degree ofconfidence that the inlined content found in the payload of a given APImessage payload is identical to the original version of inlined contentwhich was previously optimized and cached. In other words, that there isa shared identity between the two.

Specifically, a hash of the extracted bytes could be compared with thehash of the objects currently cached on the CDN to check whether theextracted bytes are already optimized and available in the cache. (Notethat optimized versions of the inlined content could have metadataindicating the hash of the original, for comparing to the extractedbytes.) If the bytes are already optimized, the CDN server can replacethe extracted bytes with the optimized bytes in the payload and thentransmit the API message to the client.

Alternatively, the position of the extracted bytes in the payload couldbe used as an indicator and compared against position information thatis associated with optimized cached versions thereof. (In other words,the optimized instances of inlined content can be associated withposition information indicating where the original inlined content—fromwhich the optimized version was created—had been located in the payloadfrom which they were extracted.) Such positioning information mayinclude one or more of the following: byte-ranges, key names in the caseof JSON payload, row and column numbers in the case of CSV payload, tagnames in the case of XML, or the subpath in the structured payload wherethe bytes were extracted from.

2.5 Transmit to Optimization Service

If the extracted bytes corresponding to an instance of inlined contentare not found in the cache of the CDN server, then they are transmittedto another service where appropriate optimization can be applied. Thisprocess could be a separate process running on the CDN server handlingthe API traffic (CDN server 101), or a process running on anothermachine in the CDN. Information about the API and/or client device maybe included with the transmission.

There may be many optimization services depending on content type. Forexample, if the extracted bytes contain base64 encoded image bytes, animage optimizing service could be utilized. If the extracted bytesrepresent HTML, JS, or CSS, the bytes could be sent to a front endoptimizing (FEO) service that can remove whitespace and minify thepayload.

In the “cache-miss” scenario, the CDN server can wait for the optimizedobjects to return from the optimization service, or it can send the APImessage with un-optimized objects to the client and cache the optimizedversions when they return from the optimization service. The CDN servermay choose to cache the optimized bytes depending upon how frequentlythe bytes are requested by various clients. The verification metadatapreviously described in 2.4, such as the hash of the original inlinedcontent and position information, can be stored with this optimizedversion.

2.6 Optimization Service

An optimization service can optimize an instance of inlined contentbased on a number of factors, including but not limited to the clientdevice's capabilities, network characteristics and metrics, and the sizeof the extracted bytes. A variety of such techniques are known in theart. The teachings hereof are agnostic to the optimization routines thatare used. Some examples of optimization routines are provided below:

-   -   When the detected mime-type is an image, the image can be sent        to an image optimizing service (IOS) to optimize the base64        encoded image bytes. The CDN server typically also transmits        metadata that may be useful to the IOS for optimization, for        example: the original headers of the request generated by the        client and any configuration that applies to optimizing the        payload. IOS may first convert the base64 encoded image bytes to        an image and then apply optimization as per the customer        configuration, or optimize the base64 encoded bytes directly.        The optimized bytes can be cached on the image optimizing        service along with any metadata that can assist the service to        prevent re-optimizing, including information such as the entire        incoming base64 encoded image bytes, hash of the base64 encoded        bytes, hash of the first N bytes of the base64 encoded bytes,        the request URL indicating the API endpoint, and position of the        inlined image. The optimized image returned by the image        optimizer to the CDN server can then be injected into the        payload replacing the image bytes originally inlined therein.    -   If the detected mime-types are either of HTML, CSS, or JS, such        content could be passed to front end optimization (FEO) service        for removal of white spaces or for minification. The service        typically refrains from minifying JS bodies as it is prone to        change variable names that can break the page's functionality        when executed together with other JS on the page.    -   If the detected type of content is a URL, the CDN server can        check its configuration for the API endpoint to decide whether        or not it can perform an HTTP/2 push, send HTTP headers to        perform a preload or a preconnect on the client for the resource        associated with the URL. Alternatively, it could consult the        configuration for whether or not to expand the inlined URL(s)        into the actual content bytes, or optimized versions thereof,        using the data URI format.

3.0 Offline Detection & Optimization

API payloads can also be scanned and optimized by an offline analyzingservice (OAS) to prepare in advance instructions on locating andverifying objects in the API payload. This can reduce the response timeand operational costs needed to perform the same job on-the-fly. Thisscenario is shown generally at FIG. 1B.

3.1 Offline Analyzer Service

With reference to FIG. 1B, an offline analyzing service (OAS) 104 can beintroduced into the system, to sample requests to and responses from anAPI endpoint. The OAS can sample traffic related to some or all of theAPI endpoints under a domain name. The OAS can then perform inspectionof the payload in API response messages, first to detect the format andthen to detect any instances of inlined content that potentially couldbe optimized, as described earlier (e.g., in Sections 2.0, 2.1 and 2.2and otherwise above). Running the checks and routines described abovecan take significant time, so by using the OAS, they are done offline.The OAS 104 can also extract and initiate optimization of any instancesof inlined content that it finds, e.g. in the manner described earlier(e.g., in Sections 2.5 and 2.6 above).

As the OAS continues to sample API requests and responses, OAS builds anAPI profile relating to the nature of the responses returned from agiven API endpoint (essentially metadata for an API endpoint). Forexample, OAS may learn over time that a given API endpoint alwaysreturns a JSON formatted payload, that it includes at least onekey-value pair whose value is base64 encoded image bytes or some othermime-type content bytes, that the detected inlined content never changesin position, byte size, or value, or that it changes only under certainconditions, for example certain end-user device identifiers, orgeographic locations. The profile may also include a hash of an entireAPI message and a hash of the first X bytes of the inlined contentdetected therein.

The OAS provides such profiles to the CDN server either periodically orupon request, which can assist the CDN server to speed up optimizing thepayload. Here is an example of the kind of information that can becaptured in an API profile, and how a CDN server can use it.

API Profile {

-   -   API endpoint: the API location (e.g., URL) to which this profile        pertains.    -   Content Location Instructions: instructions that tell the CDN        server how to quickly find one or more instances of inlined        content that could be optimized in API message payloads from the        API endpoint. Multiple sets of instructions may be included, the        selection of a particular set may depend on the client device,        geography, request parameters, or other attributes of the client        request. The content location instructions can include        directives to go to certain byte ranges and/or byte offsets with        sizes, to quickly locate a blob of data that is likely to be an        instance of inlined content that can be optimized. The content        location instructions could also be in the form of position        information as described in 2.4 above (e.g., key names,        row/column numbers, tag names, subpath, JSON Path instructions,        jq instructions, XPath instructions) that the CDN server should        search for in the payload, and extract the corresponding data.    -   Content Verification Instructions: instructions that tell the        CDN server how to verify the identity of each of instances of        inlined content, that is, that the blob of data it located via        the content location instructions really is the same as the        content that the API profile intended to find, per section 2.4        above. These instructions can include instructions to perform a        hash of the located bytes and the expected hash thereof, for        comparison. It can also include a reference to the position        information.    -   Applicable Optimization: the type of optimization that could be        applied to the content, e.g., compression, device adaptation,        and so on.    -   Updates to Content Metadata: changes to the information in the        payload (such as metadata) that may be necessary to accurately        describe the optimized content. For example, an an embedded        image [foo-image-data] may be introduced in the payload with the        metadata {image: {size: 123456, width: 100, height: 100, colors:        256, data: [foo-image-data]”, }}, where [foo-image-data] is the        image data. Upon optimization of [foo-image-data], the size,        width, height, colors, etc. needs to be updated. Alternatively,        instead of inlined image data, the image could be referenced by        URL, and metadata in the API response would still need to be        updated. In either case, the content metadata contains        instructions on how to locate and update this medata.    -   Location of Optimized Version of Content: a URL for the        optimized version of the inlined content. Many different        optimized versions may be designated with different URLs,        dependent on the client device, or other request time        information. In alternative embodiments, the actual optimized        version can be inlined into the API profile, although this makes        the profiles larger.        }

An API profile can be expressed in XML, JSON, or any other suitableformat. The CDN server 101 can fetch an API profile and cache it forsome time period, potentially with an associated TTL, and potentiallysubject to a later invalidation instruction. It could be fetched inadvance or when needed. Upon receipt of an API message from a particularAPI endpoint, the CDN server can apply the instructions in the APIprofile to quickly and efficiently find instances of inlined contentthat can be optimized, verify its identity, and swap the originalinlined content for an optimized version thereof (either from theindicated location or from local cache). In this way, much of theprocessing work needed in Section 2 is done in advance for the CDNserver.

3.2 Dynamic Structures of API Messages

Certain API endpoints may be dynamic in how they structure their APIresponses. For example, while an API endpoint may always respond with aJSON-formatted payload, the arrangement of key-value pairs inlined inthe payload may differ across requests. Alternatively, an API endpointmay always have the same arrangement but the content inlined may changefrequently. In both of the above cases, the API profile developed by theOAS 104 may become stale. To mitigate this issue, the OAS can beenhanced to calculate probabilities as to whether or not a certainpayload format and structure is to be expected from an API endpoint at agiven point in time and based on other factors (such as request headersand other configurations), and relay the calculated probabilities alongwith the API profile to the CDN server.

In practice, this can be implemented by adding to the API profile aconfidence score indicating (for each object of interest) the OAS'confidence level that a given API message payload from the API endpointwill have an instance of inlined content that can be optimized at thelocation specified by the content location instructions.

The process of developing such a confidence score is now described. Inone embodiment, the OAS continues to sample requests and responses tovarious API endpoints and develop the corresponding API profile. If andwhen the OAS encounters a structurally different payload for an APIendpoint which has been inspected previously, the OAS would develop anew profile (and/or modify the old one) pertaining to the newlydiscovered structure.

In one embodiment, the OAS assigns a counter value, starting from 1, toany profile it develops. When a sampled request-response to an APIendpoint satisfies a previously developed profile, the counter value ofthat profile is incremented by one.

Over a period of time, for each API endpoint, the OAS will havestatistics in the form of counter values indicating how many times aresponse has satisfied a given API profile. These counter values can beused by OAS to calculate the probability of how likely it is that apayload satisfies one profile over another. For example, the probabilityof an API profile being correct can be calculated as the current countervalue of that profile divided by the sum of the counter values of allprofiles pertaining to the same API endpoint.

All profiles developed for each of the API endpoints and theirprobability values could be periodically relayed to the CDN server 101.Upon receipt of an API message from the API endpoint, the CDN servercould then consult the top ‘N’ API profiles (where N is configurable)for optimizing the payload, in the order of highest probabilities first.In the event the profile with the highest probability does not satisfythe actual contents of the payload, the CDN server notifies the OAS fora potential correction and the CDN server could either fallback toattempt the profile with the next highest probability or return thepayload unchanged to the client.

If the OAS receives a notification from the CDN server that the profilewith a given probability failed, the OAS could then increase itssampling rate for sampling request-responses to a given API endpoint, toimprove its discovery.

Here is an example of an API profile with confidence scores and contentlocation instructions, expressed in XML format:

<api-endpoint>https://example.com/api/products</api-endpoint>

<payload-info>

<confidence>0.78</confidence>

<mime-type>image</mime-type>

<location>

-   -   <byte-start>100</byte-start>    -   <byte-end>28000</byte-end>

</location>

<location>

-   -   <byte-start>28100</byte-start>    -   <byte-end>90000</byte-end>

</location>

<optimization>

-   -   <service>IM</service>    -   <compression>50%</compression>

</optimization>

</payload-info>

<expected-savings>0.15</expected-savings>

In lieu of global settings, each CDN content provider customer can beassociated with a policy on what confidence levels are necessary toinvoke optimization for its API traffic falling under a given APIprofile. As an example, the above API profile can be associated with thefollowing triggering logic:

<api-endpoint>https://example.com/api/products</api-endpoint>

<levels>

<level>

-   -   <confidence>more than 0.6</confidence>    -   <expected-savings>more than 0.2</expected-savings>    -   <apply-optimization>true</apply-optimization>

</level>

<level>

-   -   <confidence>less than 0.3</confidence>    -   <expected-savings>more than 0.4</expected-savings>    -   <apply-optimization>false</apply-optimization>

</level>

</levels>

4.0 Additional Use Cases Enabled by Offline-Based Detection &Optimization Techniques

When the OAS 104 processes an API message payload, it could developadditional information for inclusion in the profile as to whether thepayload could be compressed differently based on the type of objectsinlined in the payload. For example, a JSON-formatted payload withmostly numbers inlined therein may be represented in a smaller bytefootprint as a Concise Binary Object Representation (CBOR) payload andtherefore, the profile developed by the OAS could include instruct theCDN server to perform a CBOR or MSGPACK compression on the payload, asopposed to GZiP or other traditional compression algorithms, for clientssupportive of these compressions.

The OAS could be further enhanced to recursively download the contentreferenced by the URLs inlined in the payloads and inspect them. Theinspection of these inlined URLs can be used to develop relationshipsbetween various payloads, such that it is possible to estimate that (forexample) payload A inlines a URL that may load payload B that may loadpayload C and so on. When such a pattern is discovered by the OAS, theOAS could include in the API profile a list of URLs that may be soonrequested by the client. This could enable a CDN server to not onlyprefetch, preload, or push dependent content in its cache and on theclient, but also load in its cache (or fetch from a peer/parent/origin)the content that depends upon the preloaded content. Alternatively, theOAS could prepare webpack/web-bundles that contain the sequentiallydownloaded content. The webpack could be prefetched, pushed, orpreloaded on the CDN server or the client.

5.0 Optimization of Referenced Content

The content downloaded from inlined URLs in the API message payload isreferred to as referenced content. Referenced content can be analyzed,the content-type determined, and then optimized in the same manner asdescribed earlier for inlined content. The optimized versions can thenbe ready if and when a client's request for them arrives.

6.0 Additional Embodiments

Those skilled in the art will recognize a variety of variations to themethods and systems described herein. For example, while optimization ofinlined content in API messages is typically used in downstream APIresponses, the teachings hereof also apply, without limitation, tooptimize inlined content in upstream API messages that a client issending (e.g., POSTs) to an API endpoint. Further, while optimizableinlined content typically would be in the payload of an API message, insome cases it may be possible that such content is found in a header.

7.0 Computer Based Implementation

The teachings hereof may be implemented using conventional computersystems, but modified by the teachings hereof, with the componentsand/or functional characteristics described above realized inspecial-purpose hardware, general-purpose hardware configured bysoftware stored therein for special purposes, or a combination thereof,as modified by the teachings hereof.

Software may include one or several discrete programs. Any givenfunction may comprise part of any given module, process, executionthread, or other such programming construct. Generalizing, each functiondescribed above may be implemented as computer code, namely, as a set ofcomputer instructions, executable in one or more microprocessors toprovide a special purpose machine. The code may be executed using anapparatus—such as a microprocessor in a computer, digital dataprocessing device, or other computing apparatus—as modified by theteachings hereof. In one embodiment, such software may be implemented ina programming language that runs in conjunction with a proxy on astandard Intel hardware platform running an operating system such asLinux. The functionality may be built into the proxy code, or it may beexecuted as an adjunct to that code.

While, in some cases above, a particular order of operations performedby certain embodiments is set forth, it should be understood that suchorder is exemplary and that they may be performed in a different order,combined, or the like. Moreover, some of the functions may be combinedor shared in given instructions, program sequences, code portions, andthe like. References in the specification to a given embodiment indicatethat the embodiment described may include a particular feature,structure, or characteristic, but every embodiment may not necessarilyinclude the particular feature, structure, or characteristic.

FIG. 2 is a block diagram that illustrates hardware in a computer system200 upon which such software may run in order to implement embodimentsof the invention. The computer system 200 may be embodied in a clientdevice, server, personal computer, workstation, tablet computer, mobileor wireless device such as a smartphone, network device, router, hub,gateway, or other device. Representative machines on which the subjectmatter herein is provided may be a computer running a Linux orLinux-variant operating system and one or more applications to carry outthe described functionality.

Computer system 200 includes a microprocessor 204 coupled to bus 201. Insome systems, multiple processor and/or processor cores may be employed.Computer system 200 further includes a main memory 210, such as a randomaccess memory (RAM) or other storage device, coupled to the bus 201 forstoring information and instructions to be executed by processor 204. Aread only memory (ROM) 208 is coupled to the bus 201 for storinginformation and instructions for processor 204. A non-volatile storagedevice 206, such as a magnetic disk, solid state memory (e.g., flashmemory), or optical disk, is provided and coupled to bus 201 for storinginformation and instructions. Other application-specific integratedcircuits (ASICs), field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) or circuitrymay be included in the computer system 200 to perform functionsdescribed herein.

A peripheral interface 212 may be provided to communicatively couplecomputer system 200 to a user display 214 that displays the output ofsoftware executing on the computer system, and an input device 215(e.g., a keyboard, mouse, trackpad, touchscreen) that communicates userinput and instructions to the computer system 200. However, in manyembodiments, a computer system 200 may not have a user interface beyonda network port, e.g., in the case of a server in a rack. The peripheralinterface 212 may include interface circuitry, control and/orlevel-shifting logic for local buses such as RS-485, Universal SerialBus (USB), IEEE 1394, or other communication links.

Computer system 200 is coupled to a communication interface 216 thatprovides a link (e.g., at a physical layer, data link layer,) betweenthe system bus 201 and an external communication link. The communicationinterface 216 provides a network link 218. The communication interface216 may represent an Ethernet or other network interface card (NIC), awireless interface, modem, an optical interface, or other kind ofinput/output interface.

Network link 218 provides data communication through one or morenetworks to other devices. Such devices include other computer systemsthat are part of a local area network (LAN) 226. Furthermore, thenetwork link 218 provides a link, via an internet service provider (ISP)220, to the Internet 222. In turn, the Internet 222 may provide a linkto other computing systems such as a remote server 230 and/or a remoteclient 231. Network link 218 and such networks may transmit data usingpacket-switched, circuit-switched, or other data-transmissionapproaches.

In operation, the computer system 200 may implement the functionalitydescribed herein as a result of the processor executing code. Such codemay be read from or stored on a non-transitory computer-readable medium,such as memory 210, ROM 208, or storage device 206. Other forms ofnon-transitory computer-readable media include disks, tapes, magneticmedia, SSD, CD-ROMs, optical media, RAM, PROM, EPROM, and EEPROM, flashmemory. Any other non-transitory computer-readable medium may beemployed. Executing code may also be read from network link 218 (e.g.,following storage in an interface buffer, local memory, or othercircuitry).

It should be understood that the foregoing has presented certainembodiments of the invention but they should not be construed aslimiting. For example, certain language, syntax, and instructions havebeen presented above for illustrative purposes, and they should not beconstrued as limiting. It is contemplated that those skilled in the artwill recognize other possible implementations in view of this disclosureand in accordance with its scope and spirit. The appended claims definethe subject matter for which protection is sought.

It is noted that any trademarks appearing herein are the property oftheir respective owners and used for identification and descriptivepurposes only, and not to imply endorsement or affiliation in any way.

The invention claimed is:
 1. A method performed at a cache server foroptimizing content inlined in API messages, comprising: receiving, froman application programming interface (API), an API message that the APIis sending to a client, the API message using an arbitrary format tosend content; obtaining a set of content location instructionsassociated with the API; applying the set of content locationinstructions to the API message, so as to locate an instance of inlinedcontent within the arbitrary format of the API message; after locatingthe instance of inlined content, taking at least one action from thefollowing group of actions: i) searching a local cache for an optimizedversion of the instance of inlined content, and upon finding theoptimized version, swapping the optimized version into the API messagefor the instance of inlined content, ii) requesting an optimized versionof the instance of inlined content from a remote repository, and uponreceiving the optimized version, swapping the optimized version into theAPI message for the instance of inlined content, and, iii) initiating anoptimization process to create an optimized version of the instance ofinlined content; wherein the API is associated with an API endpoint thatcomprises at least part of a URL, and the set of content locationinstructions are associated therewith.
 2. The method of claim 1, whereinthe set of content location instructions comprise at least one of: abyte offset and a byte range.
 3. The method of claim 1, wherein the setof content location instructions designate a logical location of theinstance of inlined content within the API message.
 4. The method ofclaim 3, wherein the designated logical location is expressed as atleast one of the following: a key-value pair, a row name, a column name,a tag name, a subpath.
 5. The method of claim 1, wherein the instance ofinlined content is located in a payload of the API message.
 6. Themethod of claim 1, wherein the optimization process is executed out ofband.
 7. The method of claim 1, further comprising: initiating theoptimization process in response to a failure to find the optimizedversion in the local cache or the remote repository.
 8. The method ofclaim 1, wherein the optimized version is adapted for the client.
 9. Themethod of claim 1, wherein the API message has a payload that uses astandardized data interchange format.
 10. The method of claim 9, whereinthe standardized data interchange format comprises the arbitrary format.11. The method of claim 9, wherein the data interchange format comprisesat least one of: JSON, XML, CSV, TSV, and, a delimiter-separated-valueformat other than CSV or TSV.
 12. The method of claim 1, wherein theinstance of inlined content has a type selected from the group of typesthat is: image, HTML, CSS, Javascript, URL, numerals.
 13. A methodperformed at a cache server for optimizing content inlined in APImessages, comprising: receiving, from an application programminginterface (API), an API message that the API is sending to a client, theAPI message using an arbitrary format to send content; obtaining a setof content location instructions associated with the API; applying theset of content location instructions to the API message, so as to locatean instance of inlined content within the arbitrary format of the APImessage; after locating the instance of inlined content in the APImessage: obtaining a set of content verification instructions associatedwith the instance of inlined content, applying the set of contentverification instructions to verify an identity of the instance ofinlined content, and, upon successful verification of the instance ofinlined content, taking at least one action from the following group ofactions: i) searching a local cache for an optimized version of theinstance of inlined content, and upon finding the optimized version,swapping the optimized version into the API message for the instance ofinlined content, ii) requesting an optimized version of the instance ofinlined content from a remote repository, and upon receiving theoptimized version, swapping the optimized version into the API messagefor the instance of inlined content, and, iii) initiating anoptimization process to create an optimized version of the instance ofinlined content.
 14. The method of claim 13, wherein the set of contentverification instructions comprise instructions to hash at least aportion of the instance of inlined content and compare the result to agiven hash value.
 15. A method performed at a cache server foroptimizing content inlined in API messages, comprising: receiving, froman application programming interface (API), an API message that the APIis sending to a client, the API message using an arbitrary format tosend content; obtaining a set of content location instructions and aconfidence score associated with the API; the confidence scoreindicating a confidence that the API message contains content locatableby the set of content location instructions; determining whether toapply the set of content location instructions based at least in part onthe confidence score; upon a determination to apply the set of contentlocation instructions, applying the set of content location instructionsto the API message, so as to locate an instance of inlined contentwithin the arbitrary format of the API message; after locating theinstance of inlined content, taking at least one of the followingactions: i) searching a local cache for an optimized version of theinstance of inlined content, and upon finding the optimized version,swapping the optimized version into the API message for the instance ofinlined content, ii) requesting an optimized version of the instance ofinlined content from a remote repository, and upon receiving theoptimized version, swapping the optimized version into the API messagefor the instance of inlined content, and, iii) initiating an out of bandprocess to create an optimized version of the instance of inlinedcontent.
 16. The method of claim 15, further comprising: observing, overa time period, multiple API messages sent by the API; learning thelocation of inlined content in the API messages from the observedmultiple API messages; and, generating the confidence score as aprobability that a given API message will have inlined content locatablebased on the learning.
 17. The method of claim 16, wherein theconfidence score is expressed as a probability.
 18. A system foroptimizing content inlined in API messages, comprising: one or moreservers having circuitry forming at least one processor and memoryholding program instructions for execution on the at least one processorto operate to the one or more servers to: receive, from an applicationprogramming interface (API), an API message that the API is sending to aclient, the API message using an arbitrary format to send content;obtain a set of content location instructions associated with the API;apply the set of content location instructions to the API message, so asto locate an instance of inlined content within the arbitrary format ofthe API message; after locating the instance of inlined content, take atleast one action from the following group of actions: i) search a localcache for an optimized version of the instance of inlined content, andupon finding the optimized version, swapping the optimized version intothe API message for the instance of inlined content, ii) request anoptimized version of the instance of inlined content from a remoterepository, and upon receiving the optimized version, swapping theoptimized version into the API message for the instance of inlinedcontent, and, iii) initiate an optimization process to create anoptimized version of the instance of inlined content; wherein the API isassociated with an API endpoint that comprises at least part of a URL,and the set of content location instructions are associated therewith.19. A system for optimizing content inlined in API messages, comprising:one or more servers having circuitry forming at least one processor andmemory holding program instructions for execution on the at least oneprocessor to operate to the one or more servers to: receive, from anapplication programming interface (API), an API message that the API issending to a client, the API message using an arbitrary format to sendcontent; obtain a set of content location instructions associated withthe API; apply the set of content location instructions to the APImessage, so as to locate an instance of inlined content within thearbitrary format of the API message; after locate the instance ofinlined content in the API message: obtain a set of content verificationinstructions associated with the instance of inlined content, apply theset of content verification instructions to verify the identity of theinstance of inlined content, and, upon successful verification of theinstance of inlined content, take at least one action from the followinggroup of actions: i) search a local cache for an optimized version ofthe instance of inlined content, and upon finding the optimized version,swapping the optimized version into the API message for the instance ofinlined content, ii) request an optimized version of the instance ofinlined content from a remote repository, and upon receiving theoptimized version, swapping the optimized version into the API messagefor the instance of inlined content, and, iii) initiate an optimizationprocess to create an optimized version of the instance of inlinedcontent.
 20. A system for optimizing content inlined in API messages,comprising: one or more servers having circuitry forming at least oneprocessor and memory holding program instructions for execution on theat least one processor to operate to the one or more servers to:receive, from an application programming interface (API), an API messagethat the API is sending to a client, the API message using an arbitraryformat to send content; obtain a set of content location instructionsand a confidence score associated with the API; the confidence scoreindicating a confidence that the API message contains content locatableby the set of content location instructions; determining whether toapply the set of content location instructions based at least in part onthe confidence score; upon a determination to apply the set of contentlocation instructions, apply the set of content location instructions tothe API message, so as to locate an instance of inlined content withinthe arbitrary format of the API message; after locating the instance ofinlined content, take at least one of the following actions: i) search alocal cache for an optimized version of the instance of inlined content,and upon finding the optimized version, swapping the optimized versioninto the API message for the instance of inlined content, ii) request anoptimized version of the instance of inlined content from a remoterepository, and upon receiving the optimized version, swapping theoptimized version into the API message for the instance of inlinedcontent, and, iii) initiate an out of band process to create anoptimized version of the instance of inlined content.